Unlike Samsung, Google doesn’t really advertise the Assistant’s automation capabilities.

But which is actually better?

Which Is More Accessible?

Samsung One UI 5 device settings

That’s quite a lot of steps.

That means, “IF [trigger], THEN [action]”.

Google asks you to choose a jot down of Routine before you proceed: Personal or Household.

Google app settings

you’re able to even use an image from your gallery for the same.

On Google, these presets are available as soon as you bring up the Routines page.

Which Is Easier to Activate?

Google Assistant settings menu

Manual Activation

Both tools allow creating a Home screen widget and using voice commands.

When using voice commands, Google Assistant doesn’t intuitively recognize your intent to start a certain routine.

Time-Based Activation

Both tools allow time-based activation.

Google Assistant Routines main page

For instance, you’re able to set both tools to activate your work routine at 9 AM.

Location-Based Activation

Google Assistant does not allow setting a location-based trigger.

This affects battery life.

Modes tab on Samsung Modes and Routines

Which Offers More Control?

Modes and Routines supports creating custom actions too via the “Ask Bixby” command.

Time-based activation seems to fail when you set a custom action to Google Assistant routines.

Discover menu on Samsung Modes and Routines

There are neither enough triggers nor enough actions.

Most of the supported actions are just things you could already ask Google Assistant directly.

Modes and Routines is easy to find, understand, and use.

Modes and Routines widget turned on and turned off

It also has more triggers and actions, and offers better presets.

As a gear automation tool, Modes and Routines absolutely smokes Google Assistant Routines.

Set a voice command to trigger Google Assistant routine

Bixby accepting voice command to start a routine

Samsung Modes and Routines time-based routine activation

Google Assistant Routines time-based routine activation

Routine activation at sunrise on Google Assistant Routines

Wi-Fi strength routine on Samsung Modes and Routines

Streaming video routine on Samsung Modes and Routines

Save battery routine on Samsung Modes and Routines

Actions on Samsung Modes and Routines

Actions on Google Assistant Routines

Samsung Modes and Routines custom action via Bixby Voice

Ongoing routine notification on Samsung

Bixby stopping an ongoing routine on Samsung

Set running time for a routine on Samsung Modes and Routines